Sweet Venom: A Why Choose Romance

The past few days have been crazy. After everything that has come to light, the guys and I are finally all on the same page. Everyone seems excited about the baby. I have no doubt that if we can keep our shit together, this baby will have three amazing dads, but this is new for all of us. We are clearly all fucked up beyond measure, but I think it’s why we work. Standard conventions never did, so we made our own way.

After Tatum showed up while Ellis was recounting his story about the nursery and his ex, Jacinda, we all listened intently one more time. It was as though reliving his pain with him was somehow healing our own. Both men viewed Ellis as this unbreakable, stony, unfeeling man, but the truth was, inside he was hurting. But so were Sebastian and Tatum. They all had these gnarly stains on their pasts that threatened to steal their futures. They couldn’t help but feel like their histories defined them and marked them as unworthy, and I knew that feeling all too well.

At some point, all that needed to be said had been shared, and we began to clean up, picking up all the pieces of the mess Ellis created in a fit of rage and panic. But my involvement in the cleanup process was short-lived when Tate caught me righting a bookshelf. Every eye in the room turned to glare at me hard when he scolded me for lifting, and honestly, by that point, I was done anyway. I was more than fucking tired after everything.

I went to my room and took a shower. I needed to release all the stress and tension that had built up inside me over the past few hours, and when I came out, I had every intention of heading back out to check on the guys, but instead, I flopped down on my bed. Sleep was calling my name hard, and the thought of choosing a man to sleep with was too much. I have no idea what sleeping will look like, but right now, it’s also the last thing I can do. I’ve been tossing and turning for the past hour, and now I’m fucking hungry.

Throwing the covers off, I grab my robe since I sleep naked and throw it on before searching out some late-night snacks. The only thing that sucks is, I’m craving something sweet, and those are things I usually don’t keep around, but I know Ellis loves ice cream, so I’m hopeful there’s some left in the freezer from a cheat day. When I get to my door, I quietly push it open, knowing that Tate is asleep on the couch. I know he stayed up late helping Sebastian clean up the place and empty the room Ellis kept as a shrine to his ex and the baby she lost. That story breaks my fucking heart, but it’s also the reason our story exists. Were it not for those scars shaping his heart, I can’t say we’d be here today living the way we are.

I pull open the freezer, and I can’t help but squeal when I find a carton of vanilla ice cream. I throw my hand over my mouth when I remember Tate. Slowly, I close the freezer and forego a bowl, instead going straight for the spoons. Then, popping the lid off, I dive in, and I can’t help but moan around the first bite I take. The sugary sweetness immediately quenches my craving and quietes the rumbling of my stomach all at once.

Warm arms wrap around me from behind and kiss my shoulder. ‘All that moaning made me want a taste.’

‘I’m sorry. I was trying to be quiet, but I had a craving, and I was hungry.’ I shove my spoon back into the carton and then hold it up for Tate to take a bite, and he does so ravenously.

‘Hmm, that’s good, but that’s not what I want a taste of.’

He spins me around and lifts me onto the counter before pulling at the tie keeping my robe closed. ‘You’re so fucking beautiful. I want you to eat that ice cream while I feast on this pretty pussy.’

Fuck, his words make my pussy clench, and I don’t even get a chance to respond before he’s spreading me wide, and his tongue is spearing my hole. ‘Oh god.’ My hand rushes into his hair to hold him in place. ‘You feel so good.’

He pulls back and says, ‘Eat, or I’ll stop.’

Damn, I don’t need to be told twice. I pick up the spoon and scoop up a heaping amount to lick, and just as its coolness hits my lips, his tongue runs between my folds. I’m making more than a mess of myself. Tate can eat pussy like a man starving for his last meal, and while my ice cream tastes hella good, I can barely keep my mouth closed long enough to swallow. It’s running down my chin and dripping onto my tits. The chill makes my nipples stand at full attention. I shove the spoon in my mouth, devouring the last bite as he plunges two fingers in deep. My eyes flutter closed on a long moan. I know I have a healthy sexual appetite. I love sex, but damn if my hormones aren’t turning me into a damn fiend.

His fingers curl, and he hits that spot he knows I like. Those long, tattooed fingers and his tongue working my pussy have me on the brink of coming, but it’s then that another set of warm lips assaults my senses as they latch around one of my nipples. My eyes flash open to find Sebastian’s hooded gaze locked on me as he sucks my tit hard, and my heart thrashes inside my chest with a mix of fear and excitement. He’s been the one resistant to all of this, and he only just told me he was all in. However, I didn’t expect this level. I know he shared me with Ellis, but I didn’t get the impression he liked it. He’s told me he doesn’t want to share.

Releasing my breast with a pop, he says, ‘You made a fucking mess on my tits.’ He nips at my nipple enough to sting before licking his way across my breastbone and pulling my other ice cream-covered nipple into his mouth, just as Tate sucks my clit hard into his mouth, and I detonate. The adrenaline, the hormones, the multiple sets of hands—all too much for me to resist.

‘Fuck, your pussy tastes so good,’ Tate says as he pumps me through my orgasm, licking up all my juices.

‘You want more, mia piccolo vipera?’ Sebastian asks as he kisses his way up my neck.

‘God, yes,’ I rasp as my hand trails down his bare chest, dipping under the waistband of his sleep pants to stroke his hard, silky cock. He pumps into my hand once, and I feel a drip of pre-cum that has me begging, ‘Please, I need you.’

‘And I want to keep you. Is this what you want? You want both of us?’ he asks as his lips brush over mine teasingly.

‘I want to taste you?’ I feel him smile against my cheek as the hand he has on my breast tweaks my nipple sending delicious tendrils of pleasure straight to my core.

‘You want my cock in that pretty mouth?’ I nod adamantly as he pulls back, only to cross the room and grab a chair from the dining area. He sets it in the middle of the kitchen as Tate kisses the insides of my thighs, only to stand and pull me into his arms. As he kisses me deep, I can taste my arousal all over his tongue, and it spurs me on. It’s so dirty, and I want more. I wrap my legs around him tight, pushing his cock against my throbbing clit where I need it most.

He doesn’t take me far. Without words, he knew what the chair was for, because he breaks our kiss and says, ‘Unwrap your legs, babe. It’s time to ride my cock.’ No sooner has he sat in the chair with me straddling his lap than he’s flipped the band of his shorts down and is running his tip through my swollen lips.

‘Please, Tate. Don’t tease me.’ I’m so turned on. I’ll probably come the second he seats himself.

I feel his thick head nudge my entrance, and I push down before he thinks of teasing me again. ‘Fuck, babe. I’ll never get enough of your pussy wrapped around my dick.’ I bottom out on the first thrust, more than ready to take him. His hands slide my robe off my shoulders, leaving me entirely on display, naked in the middle of the kitchen, while I start riding his dick. I brace my hands on his shoulders and throw my head back when his mouth latches around one of my sensitive nipples.

‘I’m going to need you to open those eyes while you suck my dick. You know the rules.’ Fuck. I right myself and open my eyes just as I find Sebastian standing behind Tate, dripping vanilla ice cream all over his cock. Holy hell. ‘I heard you were hungry, and you need to feed my baby. Lick it clean, mia piccolo vipera.’

I slow my pace on Tate to lean in and take Sebastian into my mouth. I’ve wanted to tease that damn piercing since I saw it. I start by taking his tip into my mouth, sucking it clean before running my tongue along the underside of his shaft, collecting all the drips of vanilla ice cream that are threatening to fall. Tatum’s thumb finds my clit, and he starts to rub slow circles as he sucks on the side of my neck while I rock against him. I’m not ready for this to end. If I keep riding him hard, I’ll come before I’m ready. Placing my hand at the base of Sebastian’s cock, I swallow him deep, taking him down my throat as I moan around his length, completely drunk off having him this way. His hand weaves through my hair as I feel his deep groan rumble through his body. Fuck. My pussy clenches, and Tate notices.

‘My dirty girl likes sucking cock,’ Tate says before adding, ‘That pussy is strangling my cock with his dick in your mouth.’

Sebastian’s hand tightens in my hair, and he pulls me off his cock so my eyes are on him when he says, ‘I love knowing my dick makes your pussy throb with need.’ Those words are so much more. It’s why he made sure my eyes were on his when he delivered them. Sebastian was the most resistant. It was all or nothing. I think that’s partly because, in his mind, if I was with another man, it meant I didn’t want him, but that couldn’t be further from true. I want them. I love them all differently but equally all the same. Reaching out, I take hold of his cock and stroke it, never taking my eyes off his, ensuring he knows that, while another man is bringing me pleasure, it doesn’t take away from what I have with him.

Tate’s hands are deliciously groping my ass when I slip Sebastian’s dick back into my mouth, taking him in down to his base. If his hiss of pleasure wasn’t confirmation enough that he’s all in and understands my level of devotion, his next words are. ‘Are you going to continue to watch from the shadows or join us? Her ass is just as good as her pussy.’

Those words aren’t lost on me. They are the exact ones Ellis said to him the first night they shared me by the pool. My stomach flutters in anticipation. I need this moment. We need this moment. If this is going to work, we all have to choose this. The choices we make right here tonight will shape our future. We all have to want this.

Ellis doesn’t give a verbal response. Instead, I feel him at my back. His strong hands slowly glide down my back, blazing a trail of heat in their wake that makes me clench. ‘Fuck,’ Tate pants into the crook of my neck, ‘Your pussy chokes my cock so good when you get greedy.’

His words of praise haven’t even finished before he spreads my cheeks wide, and I feel Ellis’s finger tease my tight hole. Sebastian again pulls me off his cock to find my eyes and say, ‘What do you think mia piccolo vipera? Are you ready to be claimed?’

‘You know I am,’ comes out as Tate seals his mouth around one of my nipples, and my pussy weeps.

His hands release my ass, and he finds my hips, ‘Get his dick wet, babe,’ he says as he lifts me off his cock. We both groan from the loss in tandem, but before I have time to miss him, I feel Ellis’s tip run through my swollen lips.

‘You’re so fucking beautiful like this, baby,’ Ellis says before his cock pushes in deep, making me gasp. Tatum quickly finds my mouth to swallow down all my moans. His tongue tangles with mine, and I know he can taste Sebastian on my lips.

Tate pulls back, his eyes lidded with desire, and asks, ‘Why is it so fucking sexy tasting him on your tongue?’

I don’t even get a chance to respond before Sebastian’s hand is back on my head, guiding my mouth onto his waiting cock as he answers, ‘Because I’m a part of her, and you love all of her.’

My lips have just wrapped around his cock when Ellis pulls out and starts dipping his fingers into my pussy, pulling my wetness to my rear. ‘I’m going to put my dick in this pretty ass now, baby. Tell me you want that.’

I groan loudly and nod the best I can with Sebastian’s cock down my throat. That’s when I feel Tate’s tip nudge my entrance before slipping back in easily. My greedy pussy is more than prepped and ready for him.

Ellis’s hands grip my cheeks, and I feel him spread me as his tip teases my puckered hole. His tip starts to breach my entrance, and I can’t help but feel love. All three of these men are worshiping my body and sharing me. ‘Ride him, baby. Relax and let me in,’ Ellis says as his lips graze my shoulder.

Sebastian is steadily controlling my mouth, his dick bottoming out in the back of my throat with each slow thrust. Placing my hands on Tate’s shoulders, I use my arms to push up since my feet can’t touch the floor. I’m slow to rise and find my balance, but once I do, I push back hard. Tate’s tip hits the spot deep inside that shoots tingles of sweet heat all throughout my body as Ellis slips in.

‘Fuck, you take our cocks so well. Such a good girl.’ Ellis’s words of praise melt me like they always do. I’m fully aware of my praise kink. I have a deep-seated desire to please these men. I have three sets of hands worshiping my body. Sebastian’s hand is wrapped through my hair, and with each thrust, he bottoms out in the back of my throat. His fingers splay over my scalp, caressing my head as his cock chokes my throat. Tate has one of my tits in his hot mouth as he alternates between swirling and sucking my nipple while his other hand pinches and kneads my breast. And then there is Ellis, his hand is placed low on my belly, his thumb gently stroking over my skin as I continue to ride him and Tate.

The sensations are overwhelming. I feel so fucking loved and cherished. I feel complete for the first time in my life. I place a hand on Sebastian’s hip to push him back and out of my mouth so that I can say, ‘Fuck, I’m coming.’

‘Fuck yeah, you are, baby. Now be a good girl, and let us fill you with our cum,’ Sebastian says as he slams his cock back into my mouth, shooting ropes of cum down my throat. At the same time, Ellis stills my hips, and he and Tate let go. My body feels like literal jello as I come hard from the best orgasm of my life with the three men I love more than anything.

Sebastian pulls out and smears his cum around my lips with the tip of his dick before saying, ‘Lick it up, vipera. Swallow every last drop.’ And I do so, greedily, as my pussy spasms around the pulsating dicks still deep inside my holes. Once I’ve thoroughly sucked his cock clean, Tate steals my mouth, diving deep the same way Ellis did the first time I sucked Tate’s dick.

‘I love you, Vi. This is all I want,’ Tate says as he pulls back breathless, his chest still heaving from our shared release.

I feel Ellis pull out and wrap his arms around me to lift me off Tate. ‘I’m going to take—’ Ellis starts, but a frenzied knock at the door has his words dying on his tongue.

Sebastian says, ‘Take her to her room. I’ll get the door.’

‘It’s 2am. Who the hell would be knocking on our door at 2am?’ I question.

‘We’re about to find out, but you’re going to put some damn clothes on first,’ Tate says.

Without another word, Ellis walks me down the hall.